Published in September 2016
|
Viewpoint
|
|
Jessica Hoey, Marnie L Campbell, Chad L Hewitt, Brendan Gould and Rosemary Bird
Acanthaster planci invasions: applying biosecurity practices to manage a native boom and bust coral pest in Australia (pp 213-220) |
|
Coral reef systems are in global decline. In Australia, much of this decline has been attributable to cyclic outbreaks (every ~17 years)
of the coral-feeding crown-of-thorns seastar. While a native species, when in large enough densities the seastar acts like an invasive pest.
Since 2012 the Australian government has invested significantly in a targeted control program using lethal injection. While this program
is effective for individual reefs, it is not a complete strategy for the entire Great Barrier Reef (~2,500 reefs). In order to find
a longer-term solution to the problem, in 2015, the lead author travelled to New Zealand, the United States, and Canada under a Churchill
Fellowship to understand successful aquatic integrated pest management strategies and their potential application to the Great Barrier Reef.
Meetings and workshops were convened with experts who specialise in risk assessment, categorisation, and management of aquatic invasive species.
The experts comprised academics, applied scientists, policy makers, and a not for profit community based invasive species council.
Bioinvasion management and prioritisation of management effort using risk-based frameworks were reviewed for application
to the crown-of-thorns seastar. This viewpoint is novel in its approach of applying invasive species tools and perspectives to a non-invasive,
native marine pest. Early detection and rapid response is key to preventing the transition of the seastar from natural densities
to outbreak densities. However given the seastar is a native species already established, when in outbreak mode a multifaceted
post-border management approach is essential. Private support funding models, that bridge conservation and tourism/philanthropy
have proved successful in New Zealand to supplement government funded marine reserve management – this is an approach which should be
explored by Australia to help manage the seastar. Dedicated support and commitment is needed to break the issue-attention cycle.
On the Great Barrier Reef, a dedicated biosecurity approach should be used to maintain the seastar at natural densities,
increase the time between outbreaks, protect coral cover and increase resilience of the system.
|
|
Research articles
|
|
Nicolas W.R. Lapointe, Pam L. Fuller, Matthew Neilson, Brian R. Murphy and Paul L. Angermeier
Pathways of fish invasions in the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States (pp 221-233) |
|
Non-native fish introductions are a major threat to biodiversity and fisheries, and occur through numerous pathways that vary regionally
in importance. A key strategy for managing invasions is to focus prevention efforts on pathways posing the greatest risk of future introductions.
We identified high-risk pathways for fish establishment in the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States based on estimates of relative probability
of establishment among pathways and records of previous introductions, which were considered in the context of emerging socioeconomic trends.
We used estimates of propagule pressure, species’ environmental tolerance, and size of species pool to assess the risk of establishment by pathway.
Pathways varied considerably in historic importance and species composition, with the majority of species introduced intentionally via stocking
(primarily for sport, forage, or biocontrol) or bait release. Bait release, private stocking, illegal introductions intended to establish reproducing
populations (e.g., of sport fish), aquaculture, and the sale of live organisms all create risks for future invasions in the Mid-Atlantic region.
Of these pathways, bait release probably poses the greatest risk of introductions for the Mid-Atlantic region because propagule pressure is moderate,
most released species are tolerant of local environmental conditions, and the pool of species available for transplantation is large. Our findings
differ considerably from studies in other regions (e.g., bait release is a dominant pathway in the Mid-Atlantic region, whereas illegal introduction
of sport fish is dominant in the western US and aquarium releases are dominant in Florida), demonstrating the need for regional-scale assessments of,
and management strategies for, introduction pathways.
|
|
|
Gary Montz and Jodene Hirsch
Veliger presence in residual water – assessing this pathway risk for Minnesota watercraft (pp 235-240) |
|
Zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha) have moved to many inland waters across the U.S. and trailered recreational watercraft are suggested
as a significant pathway for spread. Uncertainty exists on whether veligers in residual water (water remaining in boats after draining) are capable
of creating new infestations. Over 100 samples of residual water from boats which were exiting Minnesota lakes with established zebra mussel populations
were collected in July and August over three boating seasons (2013–2015). The majority of the boats were sport fishing boats, with most of the samples
coming from live wells and bilges. Very few veligers were found in these samples, with over 90% of the samples containing 5 or fewer veligers, and 70% had
zero veligers. Residual water volumes were generally less than 400 ml, and there was no correlation between volumes of water and numbers of veligers.
Due to factors such as low veliger density, dispersion and high veliger mortality, residual water may present a low risk for spread of this invasive species.
|
|
|
James Bracken, Nick Gust, Jeff Ross and Ashley Coutts
An assessment of the efficacy of chemical descalers for managing non-indigenous marine species within vessel internal seawater systems and niche areas (pp 241-256) |
|
This study assessed the efficacy of commercially available descalers and factors that influence their efficacy as tools for marine biosecurity management.
Laboratory experiments found calcium carbonate (CaCO3) degradation varied up to 29% (from 111 to 143 g/l)
amongst seven products tested. Increasing the concentration of hydrochloric, phosphoric and acid-surfactant descalers from 25 to 75% did not increase
the rate or total degradation of the mussel, Mytilus planulatus. Warming descaling solutions (from 11 to 26°C) significantly increased the rate
of mussel mortality, decay and total degradation in all treatments. Circulating treatments increased mussel mortality and decay rate in hydrochloric
and acid-surfactant descalers, but had no detectable effect on total degradation after 24h. Hydrochloric acid based descalers (Rydlyme®,
3H® and Dynamic Descaler®) were more effective than phosphoric acid (Barnacle Buster®) and acid-surfactant
(Triple 7 Enviroscale Plus®) treatments. Organic material was largely resistant to degradation under all treatments. The implications
for descalers as marine biosecurity tools are discussed.
|
|
|
Christine M. Moffitt, Kelly A. Stockton-Fiti and Renata Claudi
Toxicity of potassium chloride to veliger and byssal stage dreissenid mussels related to water quality (pp 257-268) |
|
Natural resource managers are seeking appropriate chemical eradication and control protocols for infestations of zebra mussels,
Dreissena polymorpha (Pallas, 1769), and quagga mussels. D. rostiformis bugensis (Andrusov, 1897) that have limited effect
on non-target species. Applications of low concentrations of potassium salt (as potash) have shown promise for use where the infestation
and treatment can be contained or isolated. To further our understanding of such applications and obtain data that could support a pesticide
registration, we conducted studies of the acute and chronic toxicity of potassium chloride to dreissenid mussels in four different water sources
from infested and non-infested locations (ground water from northern Idaho, surface water from the Snake River, Idaho, USA, surface water from
Lake Ontario, Ontario, Canada, and surface water from the Colorado River, Arizona, USA). We found short term exposure of veligers (< 24 h)
to concentrations of 960 mg/L KCl produced rapid mortality in water from three locations, but veligers tested in Colorado River water were resistant.
We used probit models to compare the mortality responses, predicted median lethal times and 95% confidence intervals. In separate experiments,
we explored the sensitivity of byssal stage mussels in chronic exposures (>29 d) at concentrations of 100 and 200 mg/L KCl. Rapid mortality occurred
within 10 d of exposure to concentrations of 200 mg/L KCl, regardless of water source. Kaplan-Meier estimates of mean survival of byssal mussels
in 100 mg/L KCl prepared in surface water from Idaho and Lake Ontario were 4.9 or 6.9 d, respectively; however, mean survival of mussels tested
in the Colorado River water was > 23 d. The sodium content of the Colorado River water was nearly three times that measured in waters from
the other locations, and we hypothesized sodium concentrations may affect mussel survival. To test our hypothesis, we supplemented Snake River
and Lake Ontario water with NaCl to equivalent conductivity as the Colorado River, and found mussel survival increased to levels observed
in tests of veliger and byssal mussels in Colorado River water. We recommend KCl disinfection and eradication protocols must be developed
to carefully consider the water quality characteristics of treatment locations.
|
|
|
Diane L. Waller, James A. Luoma and Richard Erickson
Safety of the molluscicide Zequanox® to nontarget macroinvertebrates Gammarus lacustris (Amphipoda: Gammaridae) and Hexagenia spp. (Ephemeroptera: Ephemeridae) (pp 269-280) |
|
Zequanox® is a commercial formulation of the killed bacterium, Pseudomonas fluorescens (strain CL145A), that was developed to control
dreissenid mussels. In 2014, Zequanox became the second product registered by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) for use
in open water environments as a molluscicide. Previous nontarget studies demonstrated the safety and selectivity of P. fluorescens CL154A,
but the database on the toxicity of the formulation (Zequanox) is limited for macroinvertebrate taxa and exposure conditions. We evaluated the safety
of Zequanox to the amphipod Gammarus lacustris lacustris, and nymphs of the burrowing mayfly, Hexagenia spp. at the maximum approved
concentration (100 mg/L active ingredient, A.I.) and exposure duration (8 h). Survival of animals was assessed after 8 h of exposure and again
at 24 and 96 h post-exposure. Histopathology of the digestive tract of control and treated animals was compared at 96 h post-exposure. The results
showed no significant effect of Zequanox on survival of either species. Survival of G. lacustris exceeded 85% in all concentrations at all three
sampling time points. Survival of Hexagenia spp. ranged from 71% (control) to 91% at 8 h, 89–93% at 24 h post-exposure, and 70–73% at 96 h
post-exposure across all treatments. We saw no evidence of pathology in the visceral organs of treated animals. Our results indicate that application
of Zequanox at the maximum approved concentration and exposure duration did not cause significant mortality or treatment-related histopathological
changes to G. lacustris and Hexagenia spp.
|
|
|
Tim Campbell, Todd Verboomen, Gary Montz and Titus Seilheimer
Volume and contents of residual water in recreational watercraft ballast systems (pp 281-286) |
|
Transient boaters are a known vector of aquatic invasive species. This has led to the establishment of prevention guidance
to reduce the risk of most boating activities. However, this guidance may not adequately reduce the risk of invasive species
transport in wakeboard boats due to the presence of ballast systems, which may be difficult or impossible for a boater to drain.
We documented that these watercraft transport relatively large volumes of residual water (mean water volume 31.7 L) even after
drain pumps run dry and that live organisms can be found in residual water for at least a week after use. The amount of residual
water found in ballast tanks was variable (range of 1.0 L to 86.8 L), indicating that there may be factors that would allow
for more complete drainage of ballast tanks. Analyses of the invertebrate communities from the residual water found that native
zooplankton were common in the samples, with two of the watercraft transporting small numbers of dreissinid veligers.
Future efforts should identify factors that can reduce the amount of residual water and identify what other invasive species
may potentially be transported through this new pathway. Additionally, more effort should be made to better understand
the boating behaviors of wakeboard boat users.
|
|
|
Damien R. Bontemps, Elvira Cuevas, Eileen Ortiz, Joseph M. Wunderle, Jr. and Rafael L. Joglar
Diet of the non-native spectacled caiman (Caiman crocodilus) in Puerto Rico (pp 287-296) |
|
The spectacled caiman (Caiman crocodilus) was introduced to Puerto Rico over 50 years ago with the Tortuguero Lagoon Natural Reserve (TLNR)
as its epicenter, where it is now established as an apex predator. Although concerns have been raised regarding the potential impact of this naturalized
predator on Puerto Rico’s native fauna, little was known of the caiman’s diet on the island. Therefore this study was conducted to determine the diet
of the spectacled caiman and its potential impact on island animals. For this study, measurements were obtained from 138 caimans across all life stages
(12–94 cm snout–vent length; SVL) from October 2014 to May 2015 within the TLNR. Stomach contents were retrieved and analyzed based on prey category
occurrence frequency. In addition, caiman muscle samples were obtained to determine their nitrogen and carbon isotopic signature. Insects were
the most abundant prey items encountered with 90.7% and 68.8% in hatchling (SVL < 20 cm) and juvenile (SVL = 20–59.9 cm) stomach respectively.
In adult (SVL > 60 cm) caimans, fish remains were the most significant prey items with 38.3% frequency of occurrence. Fish, insects, and gastropods
were the only categories of ten designated prey categories to show significant variation among the three caiman age classes. This study provides novel
information on dietary habits of spectacled caimans in Puerto Rico relevant to the design of management strategies.
|
|
|
Sophie St-Hilaire, Juergen Krause, Karen Wight, Luke Poirier and Kehar Singh
Break-even analysis for a green crab fishery in PEI, Canada (pp 297-303) |
|
The Department of Fisheries and Oceans in Canada is experimenting with a commercial fishery on the European green crab (Carcinus maenas),
an invasive species in North America, to help reduce the negative impact this animal has on ecosystems and native shellfish populations.
We determined the break-even price that fishers would require for green crabs under different fishing scenarios (i.e. different gear
and catch per trap per day). We also determined, for a 21 day season, the minimum catch per trap per day for fishermen to break even
at market prices of $0.50/lb,$1/lb, and $3.50/lb. Several scenarios were profitable, but our results suggest the price of crab (dockside)
would have to be sufficiently high to motivate fishers to continue the fishing pressure needed to reduce populations of this invasive species.
The most economically profitable scenario was a fyke net by-catch fishery, similar to what currently exists on Prince Edward Island during
the eel fishing season.
|
|
|
Elena Kupriyanova, Pat Hutchings and Eunice Wong
A fully illustrated web-based guide to distinguish native and introduced polychaetes of Australia (pp 305-312) |
|
Introduction of non-native species threatens local marine biodiversity, generating substantial costs for the aquaculture and tourism industries
when native (including commercial) species are displaced. It is important that non-indigenous species are identified and controlled before they
establish locally becoming invasive pests. The important vectors contributing to human-related dispersal of marine species include ship hull biofouling,
ballast water and the aquaculture trade. Among over 80 polychaete families, fouling (Serpulidae and Sabellidae) and burrowing (Spionidae) worms are most
commonly introduced to new localities. To assist in identification of potentially invasive non-native polychaetes, a web-based guide fully illustrated
with original photographs was developed at the Australian Museum. The guide covers 66 species including 38 species of Serpulidae, 14 species of Sabellidae,
and 14 species of Spionidae. This guide is intended for use by biologists, environmental consultants, quarantine officers and port management authorities
as correct identification of species is essential for marine pest monitoring and management. The “Polychaete Identifier” will be extended to include
other potentially invasive marine species of polychaetes, as well as crustaceans and molluscs in the near future, subject to funding availability.
|
|
|
|